Skip to main content

Disneyfication of the Gospel

Coming home from second grade Sunday school, my son asked me about the Bible story he just heard: “did it really happened that way?”  I sort of paused as I realized that I was torn between being “dad” and a Bible scholar.  So I asked him: “Do want to hear the National Geographic version or Disney Channel’s?”

We had this momentary staring contest as we both realized the profundity of it all.  I was the first to blink and quickly added that there is a History Channel version; but that already has a foregone conclusion that whatever it is must be a U.S. government conspiracy involving the Illuminati and aliens…

No. Let’s not go that way.

Anyway, this brings to mind that Disney itself has mangled the fairy tales it has made movies of.  Enough sites in the internet has compared the brutal and violent fairy tales and how tame the Disney versions are compare to them (see Huffington Post). 

Having taught children’s Sunday school long ago, I sort of remember the packaged material we dished out to the kids.  They were simple and easy to handle—too simple I thought.  I cannot really compare because I never went to Sunday school myself.  But it was not as if I did not have my share of Bible stories when I was growing up.

I had something like a dozen children’s books (ca. 1964ish) on Bible stories which were pretty graphic especially as far as what happen to Joseph because of his jealous brothers were of his multi-colored coat.  As I began to ask more questions, my mom threw at me an old King James Version with inserts that had really vivid paintings (think Mel Gibson’s “The Passion of the Christ”) that gave me nightmares when I was in second grade.  This was before “The Good News Bible” which culturally neutral line drawings.  And even before "The Flying House" and "Superbook", both of which retold Bible stories in cartoons.

That "graphic" King James Version did not scar me or scare me away from the Gospel; it actually made me more curious.  It stirred my imagination.  In fact, it was imagination that drew me in—including into fairy tales.  I remembered my aunt one rainy evening telling me the story of Pinocchio from an old book (no pictures or drawings) and being kept away for nights after.  Later seeing the Disney movie was a bit of a letdown because it was not as scary as I originally imagined it to be.

It has been over ten years ago since I had this conversation with my son—and yeah, I gave him the Nat Geo version.  In fact, everything he has heard from me from then on were the stuff I taught in seminary, never mincing the brutal details and foibles of the people involved in the Bible.  Including where the confusions and doubts were: how they were interpreted and consequently why Christianity divided into so many damnations, I mean, denominations.


If fairy tales were watered down by Disney to be even less than the fairy tales they originally were, what is the effect of watering down the Bible stories to become less than what they are?  It is bad enough that the Bible itself is considered a “fairy-tale” in some circles.  How would a young Christian cope when his or her faith is critically and intellectually challenged and all he has in his defense are even less than a “fairy-tale”?

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

What Ever Happened to Job’s Wife?

You know the story, a man named Job suffered traumatic losses where fortune, family and health were wiped out almost simultaneously as a result of some divine event—but I’m not about to discuss as who is responsible for the "what's" that happened and the “why’s” behind the morality of this story.

Job virtually was left alone save for four friends who initially consoled with him and later struggled with the moral issues that I do not intend to deal with as earlier mentioned. Instead, I want to raise the question of Job’s wife. In the midst of the calamity, loss and death, she somehow survives and stays around to annoy her husband.

“Then his wife said to him, ‘Do you still hold fast your integrity? Curse God and die.’ But he said to her, ‘You speak as one of the foolish women would speak. Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?’” (Job 2:9-10a).

The only profile we have of her is Job’s reference to speaking as a “foolish” woman. His wife, at tha…

Agua Santa

(ALL PHOTOS: PENTAX K-7 + SMCP DA 18-55/3.5-5.6 AL WR)

Agua Santa is an old resort in Los Baños, Laguna, Philippines before contemporary and trendy spas became chic.  Los Baños is located south of Metro Manila, the economic and political center of the Philippines.   It was discovered by a Spanish Franciscan Missionary Pedro Bautista in early 1590 and he found that the place had hot springs and understood that the water was medicinal.  Los Baños sits in the foothills of Mt. Makiling, a scenic and dormant volcano in Laguna.



Bath houses and the main pool now empty.

In 1603, the Franciscans built a Nipa Hut that served as a hospital dedicated to the Immaculate Concepcion with the name Nuestra Señora de Agua Santa.  Eventually, Pedro Bautista was sent to Japan as Ambassador of the King of Spain in 1597 and was martyred along with his companions for their faith in Nagasaki, Japan.  They were canonized as saints on June 8, 1862.


The main pool now decrepit and deteriorating in the elements.
T…

Hapid 2016

Hapid, Ifugao - Part 3 [ Part 1 | Part 2 | Part 4 | Part 5 | Part 6]

To describe Hapid as being in the middle of nowhere may be an understatement: to go there you basically have to go north along the Pan-Philippine Highway (AH26) which veers toward the east side of Luzon, going through Nueva Ejica and Nueva Vizcaya.  Just before reaching the northern end of Nueva Vizcaya, you turn to what appears to be a secondary provincial road that goes to Ifugao; the road narrows a bit but traffic becomes way lighter as you realize that most of the traffic on the Pan-Philippine Highway is going further to Tuguegarao, Cagayan.  That “secondary” road ultimately takes you to Banaue, the tourist destination known for the Rice Terraces.  Other than that, everything is uneventful.  The last major urban area was back in Nueva Vizcaya (Solano) after which the vestiges of civilization (i.e., fastfoods) are gone.

Somewhere after Solano you pass a small town called Lamut and somewhere there you turn off into a…